2024 REU Results
UW–Madison Astrophysics REU Program Summer 2024
Johann Baynes (University of the West Indies)
Bridging Radio Data Access for AGN Events
Mentor: Yjan Gordon
The IceCube experiment’s detection of High Energy Neutrinos (HEνs) offers novel insights into a more complete picture of the Universe. However, the origin of these HEνs is poorly constrained. Only two sources of HEνs have been identified to date, both radio-loud active galactic nuclei (AGNs). AGNs are promising candidates as HEν sources from their mechanisms for neutrino emission (shocks in jets and accretion flow) align plausibly with observations. They have also provided clues in narrowing the possible candidates for HEν sources. In order to cross-correlate HEνs with radio observations, databases of radio and neutrino observations are compared to ensure consistency of time, position and energy. Conversely, it is difficult for astronomers outside of radio astronomy to access these radio databases. This work focused on radio databases from ASTRON (Netherlands Institute for Radio Astronomy), CADC (Canadian Astronomy Data Center), CASDA (CSIRO ASKAP Science Data Archive) and NRAO (National Radio Astronomy Observatory). The project aimed to design and create a software tool able to access the largest radio observatories for any given area of the sky and time as well as create a framework for it to be used in correlation mapping of HEν sources. A program, RadioQuery was developed to allow for access to the databases in aggregate with the ability to query specific parameters such as right ascension, declination and radio frequency bands. The tool created will provide a scaffolding for further endeavors into correlation mapping of Heν and radio sources along with a window into multiwavelength neutrino studies. This work was supported by the National Science Foundation’s REU program in Astrophysics through NSF award AST-2150222. Additional support was provided by the Radio Astronomy Data Imaging and Analysis Lab (RADIAL) Research & Training Experience program through the National Radio Astronomy Observatory; and by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation’s Creating Equitable Pathways to STEM Graduate Education Program.
Lailyn Borum (University of Michigan at Dearborn)
Planet Habitability and Atmospheric Mass Loss
Mentor: Juliette Becker
In this project, we aim to model atmospheric mass loss in exoplanets with varying orbital parameters to assess its impact on planetary habitability. Within exoplanet research, we define a planet as habitable if its surface temperature allows liquid water to pool. Certain parameters and processes of the planet can affect this ability; for example, the rate of atmospheric loss by stellar radiation has a strong impact on a planet’s ability to retain surface water. To study this relationship, we used VPLanet, a modular code that has the ability to model water loss on exoplanets. Using a suite of VPlanet simulations, we found that the stellar age at which a planet is assumed to form its oceans has a profound effect on the computed water loss. This suggests that future research on ocean loss in exoplanets should account for the variability in the timing of when planets are able to form oceans. Next steps will involve using VPlanet to simulate the effects other parameters have on a planet’s habitability. This work was supported by the National Science Foundation’s REU program in Astrophysics through NSF award AST-2150222.
Sofija Brnovich (Loyola University of Chicago)
pSCT Camera Upgrade: Module Measurements
Mentor: Justin Vandenbroucke
The Cherenkov Telescope Array Observatory (CTAO) consists of two arrays of imaging atmospheric Cherenkov telescopes for γ-ray astronomy between 20 GeV and 300 TeV. The prototype Schwarzschild-Couder Telescope (pSCT) is a medium-sized CTAO prototype telescope that is currently undergoing an upgrade of its camera systems. We present measurements of the performance of the upgraded pSCT camera module using electrical pulse injection and optical light-emitting diode flashes. Electrical pulse injection tests demonstrate a linear relationship of the readout electronics between input and measured pulse amplitudes over a wide dynamic range. Using optical flashes, we further quantify the performance of the silicon photomultipliers and the shaping and pre-amplifying circuitry. Based on the electrical and optical test results, we present measurements of the camera module dynamic range, linearity, gain, and resolution. These metrics directly impact the expected performance of the upgraded camera for γ-ray astronomy. This work was supported by the National Science Foundation’s REU program in Astrophysics through NSF award AST-2150222.
Zahra Burroughs (SUNY College at Plattsburgh)
Galaxy Evolution of IC342: Star Formation
Mentor: Ralf Kotulla
IC342 is an intermediate spiral galaxy located in the constellation Camelopardalis, which is relatively close to the Milky Way. When observing this galaxy, unusually bright sources were spotted in the outskirts of its spirals. This shouldn’t be the case, since theoretically there would be far less gas and dust in these outer regions compared to the center, based on our observations of other galaxies. This observation posed a question; are star forming processes different in the outskirts of this galaxy than what we typically see? In answering this question, we wanted to learn more about star forming processes in rather diverse environments different from our own solar neighborhood, because for the most part we already have an understanding of these processes. To start answering these questions, we investigated star ages, their uv and h-α, and compared the sources from this galaxy to other stellar population models. Our studies found no convincing evidence that the initial mass function (IMF) changed from the center of the galaxy to the outskirts, but it was also concluded that higher resolution UV data could allow for a better study of lower mass regions. This work was supported by the National Science Foundation’s REU program in Astrophysics through NSF award AST-2150222
Eliza Canales (New Mexico Institute Of Mining & Technology)
Billowing Hydrogen: Turbulence in HII Regions
Mentor: Trey Wenger
Radio recombination lines (RRL) are an extinction-free tracer of ionized gas in Galactic HII regions. Recent interferometric RRL observations reveal ionized gas velocity gradients across some nebulae, which have been interpreted as bulk rotation of the ionized volume. We use the Australia Telescope Compact Array to obtain higher angular resolution RRL maps of several Galactic HII regions in order to test this hypothesis. These data reveal a significantly more complicated kinematic environment, which draws into question the bulk rotation hypothesis. We explore the possibility that the observed RRL kinematics trace turbulence in the ionized gas. We generate synthetic RRL data cubes from random Kolmogorov-like density and velocity fields. Qualitatively, these simple simulations reproduce the observed RRL kinematics in Galactic HII regions. Quantitatively, we use these simulations to estimate the sonic Mach number under the assumption of Kolmogorov-like turbulence. We find that supersonic turbulence is able to explain the observed ionized gas kinematics in Galactic HII regions. RRLs may thus provide a direct tracer of turbulence in massive star forming regions and constrain the scales of energy injection in the interstellar medium. This work was supported by the National Science Foundation’s REU program in Astrophysics through NSF award AST-2150222. Additional support was provided by the Radio Astronomy Data Imaging and Analysis Lab (RADIAL) Research & Training Experience program through the National Radio Astronomy Observatory; and by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation’s Creating Equitable Pathways to STEM Graduate Education Program.
Josie Carrillo (Amherst College)
Measuring Quasar Luminosities
Mentor: Kate Grier
Sydney Fowler (University of Georgia)
Cosmic Ray Anisotropy
Mentor: Paolo Desiati
This study explores the viability of the cosmic-ray dipole anisotropy induced by Earth’s orbital Compton-Getting effect, as an explanation for the observed large-scale cosmic ray anisotropy. Utilizing dedicated Python scientific libraries, the Compton-Getting effect dipole distribution was numerically evaluated and compared with actual cosmic ray data. The data was collected from HAWC γ-ray observatory, located in Mexico. The analysis reveals the comparison between the numerical calculations and experimental data of the anisotropy of the cosmic rays. The findings suggest the need for additional factors or sources to explain the anisotropic patterns. This work was supported by the National Science Foundation’s REU program in Astrophysics through NSF award AST-2150222.
Nathaniel Marcelin (University of Florida)
Decomposing bars
Mentor: Ralf Kotulla
The decomposition of galactic structures, including bars, bulges, and disks, is widely used in astro- nomical research, often utilizing software such as GALFIT, IMFIT, and other photometric modeling tools. The idea of this project is to engage in the usage of Astropy Package, Photutils to match the results of the software tools above. More specifically; through the use of Photutils, could we decompose galactic bars from their host galaxies. In the package, we utilize Photutils’s: isophote fitting capabilities to model ellipses along lines of constant brightness in galaxy images. By identifying the peak ellipticity, which corresponds to the bar structure, and defining elliptical apertures for both the bar and the outermost isophotes, we perform aperture photometry to measure the flux within these regions. This allows us to quantify the bar’s contribution relative to the total galaxy light, offering what we call the, “Bar-flux Fraction” (BFF). In this method, we utilized five barred spiral galaxies, with the Ferrer functions for the bars calculated from the paper ‘An Optimal Strategy for Accurate Bulge-to-Disk Decomposition of Disk Galaxies’ by Hua Gao and Luis C. The galaxy sample provided by Hua serves as a reference to test whether our analysis yields similar BFF values as their published Ferrer numbers. In the Hua paper, three models were employed to determine the bar’s Ferrer function. In our method, we achieved re- sults comparable to theirs. For IC 5240, their Ferrer function ranged from 12.3% to 16.2%, while our calculation yielded a BFF of 17%. Similarly, for NGC 945, Hua and Luis reported a Ferrer function between 10% and 17%, and our analysis produced a value of 13%. As our results closely align with those of Hua and Luis, this provides optimism that our method is progressing in the right direction. The slight differences in values, such as our 17% Ferrer function for IC 5240 compared to their range of 12.3% to 16.2%, could be attributed to several factors. One potential source of discrepancy is the varying treatment of flux contributions from the bulge or the underlying disk, which tends to become brighter towards the galaxy’s center. These factors may not have been fully accounted for in our initial analysis. However, with further refinement and careful consideration of these components, this method shows great potential. Once these adjustments are integrated, our approach could offer a robust and advantageous means of accurately decomposing galactic structures and isolating the bar component, ultimately providing deeper insights into the dynamics of barred spiral galaxies.
Tara Nester (Georgia Southern University)
Molecular Abundances in Space Objects
Mentor: Zoe Todd
In the early stages of Earth, it was thought to be frequently bombarded with meteorites and other space debris as it was evolving. During this period, it is thought that some of the water, organics, and volatiles that may have been necessary for prebiotic chemistry and the overall origins of life were delivered through these impacts. Currently, however, there isn’t an entirely accurate picture of the chemical contents present in asteroids and comets, which could be the source material of some of these impacts. If that is the case, then examining present-day asteroids and comets could provide insight into what was needed for life to begin. An analysis of the chemicals identified in asteroids Bennu and Ryugu, meteorite Murchison, and comet 67P was conducted to compile the types of chemicals that could be found in these types of objects. This was done in hopes that it could be used for comparison in future studies. Some of these classifications of these chemicals include polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), organosulfur compounds, hydrocarbons, heterocyclic compounds, amino acids, and aromatics. PAHs and amino acids were further examined through individual case studies. Each of the objects studied had at least one PAH present. Twenty-five amino acids were identified, five proteinogenic and twenty non-proteinogenic, all of which are present on Ryugu with some being found on Murchison. Future work on quantifying the abundances of classifications/chemicals expected from delivery and comparing these with the current commonality of each type could place constraints on the potential that impact events could have an effect on the chemical diversity on early Earth.
This work was supported by the National Science Foundation’s REU program in Astrophysics through NSF award AST-2150222.
Isaiah Persad (University of the West Indies)
Cataloguing TRAGNs in VLASS
Mentor: Eric Hooper
Active Galactic Nuclei, or AGN, are supermassive black holes at the center of galaxies that accrete surrounding material from their host galaxy. The gas that is accreted is sometimes forced outwards at relativistic speeds that are seen as two jets emitting electromagnetic radiation, most commonly seen at radio wavelengths. This study focused on the subset of AGN with three radio components observed in the ongoing Very Large Array Sky Survey (VLASS): two from the lobes and from the region of the black hole itself (the core), called TRAGNs (Triple Radio Source AGN) whose radio emissions allow us to study their orientation in space. Specifically, we quantified the apparent bending of the jets using a bending angle defined by the centroids of the core and the two lobes, as well as the radius of curvature of the circle that best fits the source image. Movement of the galaxy through the intergalactic medium is one cause of radio jet bending, and we observed how the environments, or surroundings, of the TRAGNs affected the bending jets by relating the “richness” of the environments to the degree of bending. To accomplish this, we crossmatched the sky coordinates and redshift to our data to determine whether our triple sources were associated with the environments. So far, the preliminary results show that low density environments cause lower bending angles in the jets of our TRAGNs whereas high density environments show high bending angles, which is the result that is expected. This project is part of a larger effort to study whether bent jets can realistically characterize the density of the intergalactic medium, particularly in galaxy groups that may be the location of a major component of the longstanding missing baryons. This work was supported by the National Science Foundation’s REU program in Astrophysics through NSF award AST-2150222. Additional support was provided by the Radio Astronomy Data Imaging and Analysis Lab (RADIAL) Research & Training Experience program through the National Radio Astronomy Observatory; and by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation’s Creating Equitable Pathways to STEM Graduate Education Program.
Neval Rattan (University of the West Indies)
Analyzing Transit Timing Variations
Mentor: Juliette Becker
Transit Timing Variations (TTVs) are deviations in expected transit times of exoplanets, which may occur when a planet experiences gravitational interactions with another object. TTVs are a powerful tool for deducing the orbital parameters of exoplanetary systems, as they allow for the estimation of planetary masses and eccentricities, which are otherwise not easily found from transit data. I developed a pipeline utilizing emcee, a Monte Carlo Markov Chain code, to fit a model to TTV data and extract a best-fit set of parameters and uncertainties. To validate the effectiveness of this approach, I simulated an exoplanetary system using TTVFast and generated mock TTV data. I was able to successfully constrain the orbital parameters of the simulated system, demonstrating the accuracy and reliability of the method. This pipeline can be used in future work to constrain the parameters of various multi-body orbital systems. This work was supported by the National Science Foundation’s REU program in Astrophysics through NSF award AST-2150222. Additional support was provided by the Radio Astronomy Data Imaging and Analysis Lab (RADIAL) Research & Training Experience program through the National Radio Astronomy Observatory; and by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation’s Creating Equitable Pathways to STEM Graduate Education Program.
Martina Salichs (University of Puerto Rico – Mayaguez)
Mentor: Zoe Todd
Interplanetary Dust Particles (IDPs) are residual material from early-solar system collisions and planet formation, ranging from micrometers to less than a millimeter in radius. IDP impacts are potentially a key mechanism for the exogenous delivery of molecules to Earth (Sagan 1997). In this project, we focused on chondritic IDPs, which consist of silicates, carbonates, and metals, to study the physical properties of their atmospheric descent on Earth. Within the chondritic IDPs, we distinguished the anhydrous (less dense) and hydrous (more compact) particles by varying the impactor density in the range of 0.6 g/cc to 1.8 g/cc (Flynn 2004). We developed computational models to understand how changing physical parameters such as impact angle and initial radius, help constrain the survival of prebiotic molecules. We explored distinct combinations of these parameters by varying factors such as initial velocity, while keeping others constant, and we present their impact on the obtained results. Additionally, the models include mass ablation and energy balance calculations, where the former assumes an isothermal and homogeneous atmosphere. From these calculations, we obtained temperature profiles of the particle as it descended through the atmosphere and heated up. We observed that a smaller initial velocity and a more oblique impact angle greatly contributed to achieving a lower temperature peak (i.e., they “burn up” less) since they account for a slower, more controlled descent. The lowest peak temperature reached with these conditions for a 50μm particle was ~2000 K, while the maximum peak temperature reached nearly 3000 K. As for the role of impactor density, our results suggest that lower-density IDPs burn up faster, yet to a lower temperature compared to the higher-density IDPs. Our general findings also suggest that a smaller initial velocity and a more oblique impact angle yield less mass ablation, which is favorable for chemical survival. In the near future, we aim to modify and apply this model to larger meteorites. Studying the exogenous delivery of molecules is potentially useful for understanding the origins of life on the early Earth.
Lauren Wittry (Knox College)
Investigating High-Star Forming eBOSS Galaxies
Mentor: Christy Tremonti
An open question in galaxy evolution is how massive galaxies shut off their star formation. To study this, we compare three different star formation rate indicators as applied to a sample of ~6700 star forming galaxies with log(M*) = 9 – 12 at z = 0.4 – 0.55 from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey IV Extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (eBOSS). This redshift range was chosen to ensure spectroscopic coverage of Hα while minimizing aperture bias in the 2″ fiber spectra. We examine three methods of measuring star formation rates: (1) restframe ultraviolet to optical spectral energy distribution fitting using the CIGALE code; (2) the Hα emission line from the eBOSS spectra, corrected for extinction using the Balmer decrement; and (3) the WISE W3 (12 micron) luminosity. Our results show good agreement among all three methods, and we were able to quantify systematic uncertainties connected to prior probability assumptions about dust in CIGALE. We then examine SDSS J022243.31+000635.5, a particularly interesting massive galaxy (log(M*) = 11.5) that has exceptionally high calculated star formation rates but whose spectrum shows a strong Balmer break, similar to a post-starburst. Despite being targeted for spectroscopy as a supernova host galaxy, its WISE light curve varies over a much longer time period than expected for a supernova, on the order of years rather than months. From its variability, emission line ratios, and its broad and strongly blueshifted [OIII] and Hα lines, we find that it likely contains a highly reddened Type 1.5 – 2 active galactic nucleus driving a powerful outflow.
This work was supported by the National Science Foundation’s REU program in Astrophysics through NSF award AST-2150222.